We are supposed to get out of class around 1:15 p.m. After that, it’s lunch. Most of us have been in class with minimal breaks since 6:30 yoga, so by the end of sci-tech, we’re ready to chew our own hands off with hunger. We lift ourselves from the desks we’ve been sitting in all morning and cross the veranda to the dining room.
“What do you think’s for lunch?” Alyssa asks me as we enter.
“Oh I don’t know, probably some potatoes and cauliflower, roti, rice, something that looks like yogurt…” I reply with a smirk.
“Sound’s about right,” Alyssa laughs. You can imagine our surprise when plates of potatoes, roti, a giant crock of fluffy white rice, and a mixture of intensely cooked vegetables dowsed in oil and Masala line the counter. Alyssa, I, and the other students shovel the traditional South Indian cuisine onto our plates and take seats around a long rectangular table.
“I would kill for a giant Italian sub right now,” J says through mouthfuls of sauce-covered rice.
Alex has stuffed a roti with vegetables, folds it like a burrito, and takes a bite.
“Humph. It’s not the same,” he sighs.
I, personally, could go for a big fresh salad sprinkled with pine nuts and feta cheese (we can’t eat uncooked veggies here) or a syrupy short stack of blueberry pancakes.
Hell, I’d even settle for a peanut butter and banana on wheat or a grilled cheese and tomato sandwich.
It’s not that South Indian food doesn’t taste good. In fact, it tastes awesome. Every meal, whether cooked at the institute or at a restaurant tastes great. And what makes it taste even better is the fact that you can get a full meal of roti, soup, rice, and multiple sauce-type dishes all for about $1. We can eat every meal like kings.
But the problem is the food’s more or less all the same, meal after meal, day after day. Many of us came in to this thinking “I love Indian food so much! There is no possible way I could get sick of it!” But after two only weeks, lack of variation has gotten to us, keeping us in pursuit of the oh-so-sparse American food restaurant.
I think what it comes down to is the Westerner’s need for variety. Americans have so many options for how to stimulate our palates, what to do for entertainment, what styles of clothes to wear, which games to play, how to do our hair, etc. etc. that we have very little tolerance for monotony. We’ve been brought up to expect options and possibilities.
Do you agree?
We love 47 varieties of pickles!
We need our 220 high-definition television channels!
Take New York City; It might be the representative example of our need for variety. On any given street you might find 14 different ethnic food restaurants, three theaters, a handful of art galleries, any kind of store you could want, bars, strip clubs, yoga studios, gyms, it’s like a condensed version of the corporate America variety show.
Well, I’ve taken the liberty to illustrate my experience thus far in a way we can all understand - by starting one list of things in Mysore that are predictable (lack variety) and another of things with lots of variety and are therefore unpredictable. It's not exaclty NYC:
Predictable -
1) Getting Diarrhea (and other sicknesses) - The spices, cooking methods, and bacteria in South Indian food put our weak-ass American digestive systems to shame. By now, we have all had the pleasure of experiencing what I like to call: “Uh Oh! Gotta Go!” Syndrome. Symptoms include:
* Periodic sprints to the bathroom. These come on without warning and with the force of a nuclear missile.
* Loss of appetite – We know all too well that it’ll all be back to haunt us in 15 minutes anyways.
* Absence from classes. Who can focus on work with all that commotion in the stomach?
* Episodes of water chugging to get away from dehydration station.
* Extra trips to the office to ask for yet another role of toilet paper.
My advice? Don’t be stupid like me and wait for it to go away. It is not just your body adjusting to the spices. It’s your body being mauled by bacteria it can’t handle. Take the medicine ASAP. Do it.
2) Teachers’ opinions on government, World Bank, media, consumption, politicians, corporations, globalization, science… –They’re evil.
3) Scamming rickshaw drivers – “It’s raining,” “I’m still 11kms from my home,” and “The meter is not enough” are not reasons to charge 60 rupees for a ride that should cost 30. We may be white, but we’re not morons. Maybe they should try “You owe me more because of the unjust imbalanced distribution of wealth in the world.” They might win me over with that one.
4) Women in TV commercials – television commercials seem to largely cater to upper class, Westernized individuals. They usually showcase young, pretty men and women interacting. Women are almost always wearing Western style clothing (despite the fact that nearly all the women in Mysore, regardless of age, class, or caste, wear saris and Indian-style clothes), they are and are depicted as either domestic roles or sexually. They seem to, like, be, like, the valley-girl equivalent of, like, Indians. It’s also impossible to turn on the TV for more than 10 minutes without seeing an add for skin-whitening cream. Way-to-go, Western cultural imperialism!
5) Getting dirty – just lower your standards of hygiene right from the beginning because for the next three-and-a-half months you won’t recognize the soles of your feet, or see a shiny floor.
6) The smell of burning trash – Waste management at its finest.
Unpredictable -
1) Locals’ reactions to us – Will they smile and say “hi” when they see us? Stare? Swear? Beg? This is definitely not predictable. Chances are little kids will either say “hi,” giggle and run away, or follow us in groups chirping “auntie” and asking for “biscuits.” Adults might do anything from stare to, to laugh, to swear at us in English or Kannada (usually men), smile, ignore us…it’s like puppy surprise.
2) Who will be teaching class today – I don’t know who it’s going to be, but you bet your ass, whoever it is, “We’ll continue to be impressed with the quality of teachers” (according to Dr. Rao, who reminds us this over and over and over).
3) Insect sightings – Every day it’s something new and different! Starting when little seven-year-old Evan snatches up a fat, juicy, 6-inch long millipede and sets in on the bench wear Jason and I are studying. The next day I discover the pleasant three-inch wasps – black with a bright orange stripe- in the laundry room. Then there are the psychedelic preying mantises on the pillars and finally a spider in the stairwell with a penny-sized body and legs like oversized toothpicks. I’m also pretty sure they sell cookies at some of the food stands with grasshoppers bakes into them.
- Who will show up for yoga – It’s 6:30 in the damn morning. There may be six of us, there may be 16 pulling ourselves out of bed at the ass-crack of the day just to lift out legs and touch our toes.
4) The weather –I guess you could say it’s predictably unpredictable. Chances are each day will include periods of downpour, sunshine, intense heat, high winds, coolness, and drizzle – not necessarily in this order. Because of this, I’ve taken to not bothering to prepare for anything. Otherwise, I’d need a jacket, an umbrella, a light change of cloths…so not happening.
5) Sounds – Will I wake up to someone dropping coconuts from the trees? Dogs barking? Organ music? Drums? Singing? Coughing uncontrollably? Laughing? Whatever it is, it won’t be highway noises, an airplane, or a garbage truck.
(This list is subject to revision so if you also happen to be in Mysore, give me what you got!)
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
Friday, August 24, 2007
Big Questions
A small, plain room with large windows functions as our classroom, the living room, yoga studio, and a library. In the morning, Soma, the errand/secretary boy clears out the desks and chairs and sweeps the floor before we lay our mats down for yoga.
The back wall is a bookshelf enclosed by glass doors. A TV is tucked in the corner of the room. Laminated maps of Mysore, Karnataka, India, and the world decorate the walls as if to convince us “there’s a whole world in here.”
At morning yoga, we lay our mats wall to wall. We follow the instruction of a quiet woman with a deep steady voice as other voices, songs, sounds of people doing this or that work, and a new variety of bird and animal sounds come through the window. The air is cool and comfortable until we get our blood pumping with the yoga.
I usually take a spot near the side wall in the second row, under the world map. Though the positions are basic, most struggle with them. I don’t struggle the physical stuff, but when it comes to breathing, concentration, and meditation, I may be the worst.
When we’re supposed to close our eyes, I notice mine are very much open:
“Stop staring at Russia,” I scold myself.
My eyes wander around at other people to see who’s wiggling and who’s steady.
I have thoughts like, “There’s no word for the sound of breathing.”
Sometimes I try force myself to concentrate, but it’s like counting sheep: everything goes fine for the first two or three cartoon sheep that make it over the fence, but then one of them finds a patch of grass and misses his turn, then one of your friends comes to sheer sheep number five, and you remember you want to write to that person. Then you remember all the other things you want or need to do and suddenly there’s sheep taking showers, sheep drinking beer, sheep climbing trees, sheep robbing banks – it’s sheep anarchy. But hey, at least I have the moves down.
After faking my way through yoga and breakfast, we return and take our seats for classes. In “culture and civilization,” we have a guest teacher practically every day to lecture us on a topic. On Tuesday, Dr. Rao begins by introducing Dr. Lakshmi Kathacharga, who is teaching the class on “Indian thought and value.”
Dr. Lakshmi sits reclined in a chair in a long white shirt and light pants. A thick red line is painted onto his forehead, running from his hairline to his brow, and two thicker white lines run parallel on either side of the red one. He seems to have the slightest hint of a beer gut.
Before the lecture, Dr. Rao lists off his academic accomplishments in extreme minute detail (this becomes the norm when we have guest teachers; Indians certainly don’t have any problems talking about what they’ve done):
“Dr. Kathacharga has been a professor of the University of Mysore, and at the University of Atlanta, at blah blah university in Switzerland,” Rao begins. “He has served as advisor for the blah blah blah board in Mumbai, and head administrator of the blah blah project. He has created electronic programs to translate Sanskrit into English, studies at 18 different universities and received 25 honorary degrees. He’s been to outer space, created a cure for AIDS, invented a time-travel machine and wrote six New York Times bestselling novels. During the second half of life he…” Minutes later, Dr. Lakshmi thanks Dr. Rao and begins the lecture.
He starts off by explaining what the difference between “systems” (things like computers, cars and the human body) and “users” (the things that make the systems work), and that it is the responsibility of the user to have basic knowledge of the system and provide it with what it needs to work. He also says that if the user dies, the system dies – so that the system depends on the user.
Then he says, as if it were fact, “There are five levels of the human system: the physical body, vital airs, consciousness, the mind/brain, and supreme consciousness that creates, sustains and destroys the whole of the universe.”
“Really?” I think, “This is the foundation in the East for their philosophical beliefs, for their culture, literature, social lives and education? His entire lecture centers around this “truth” the existence of a supreme consciousness.
During my entire college career, my studies have relied on the presumption of the truths of post-structuralism, namely:
- There is no true essence or fixed meaning in things.
- Things only receive meaning when humans impose it on them through the use of an arbitrary language or signifier system.
- There is nothing outside the text.
I’ve never had a strong faith in any supreme being or force, and have been conditioned to be skeptical of supreme consciousness. At first, what he says comes off as ignorant and I’m a little frustrated.
He spends a good deal of time talking about how we must eat only as much as the energy we need to function, we must go to bed at a specific time and wake up at one too, we should sleep on our right side of our bodies, and we should never have attachment to anything, because attachment leads to wastefulness (give me a breaks). And that we must see every person as yourself, and then there would be no crime, harm, or terrorism.
I begin to realize that, whoa, the entire world doesn’t think like Westerners and that school in the East (at least here and I’m assuming other places – I’d love to hear your experiences with this) is taught with a foundation based on faith and spirituality, not skepticism and spiritual lack.
While he speaks, I’m looking at this lecturer guy, who is definitely a little overweight, and whose cell phone goes off in the middle of the lecture. Then I look at Dr. Rao – he’s asleep in his chair and remains that way for at least half the lecture.
“Who are they kidding?” I think to myself. “If you’re going to preach, you should at least practice it.” His value system seems to be more of a theory than a practice.
But then, when I think about it in other ways (my mind has a tendency to play devil’s advocate with itself), some of what he says does seem to make a lot of sense, including:
“Now there is much more mental illness because the questions of purpose and spirituality are not being fulfilled,” he explains, “We are being cluttered by things that cannot fulfill our spiritual desires and needs.”
This really strikes me and I begin to think about the idea. I wrote in a previous post (wonderful/terrible part II), “Nobody really knows why we are all so bipolar now, except that it is very, very specifically human.”
Maybe it isn’t specifically human. It’s specifically Western, postmodern, existential. Is the reason we are so (self) destructive because we lack something essential – faith. Is my existential conditioning the cause of my freak outs and violence behavior? Or is it that humans are simply as naturally violent as they are good, and violence shouldn't be repressed at all? I scribble down a long list of questions his words bring to mind.
Are we too jaded?
Have we gotten to smart for our own good?
Why can’t I focus during yoga?
After class I approach the Dr. I ask him, how he thinks post-structuralist thought affects the lives of westerners; if he think it causes any problems.
"Sorry, I've never heard of this post-structuralism," he replies. "I don't know about everything."
He's never even heard of it. This sort of blows my mind...
For about a second...
then I think...
Oh screw it.
I want to live and not think about these things. I just want to be able to have fun and not care. I want to act based on what feels right. This is all the philosophical bullshit I decided I’d never think about again because it always leads to frustration and unanswered questions. But time and time again, I find myself here and it always makes me depressed until I shut it off again. I just can’t deal.
After class we all go to lunch. The cooks have prepared a typical meal of many options: some sort of rice dish, a salad-like thing, fruit, a veggie dish, paneer, Indian breads, multiple sauces. We fill our plates and dig in. A large electric bug zapper on the ceiling periodically makes sizzling sounds as it kills mosquitoes and flies.
“I’m starving!”
“me too!”
One of the students mentions a bar/club they heard about called High Octane. Another talks about one called Grandpa’s. Supposedly, these are places that cater to international students, selling all sorts of beer and liquor. Most of us can’t wait to go out and have a little fun. We aren’t thinking about the lecture anymore, or the man’s way of life. It was just another lecture like so many we’ve had in our academic careers - just interesting words.
But I’m willing to bet, sooner or later when we're freaking out the most, the big questions will burrow back into our minds.
The back wall is a bookshelf enclosed by glass doors. A TV is tucked in the corner of the room. Laminated maps of Mysore, Karnataka, India, and the world decorate the walls as if to convince us “there’s a whole world in here.”
At morning yoga, we lay our mats wall to wall. We follow the instruction of a quiet woman with a deep steady voice as other voices, songs, sounds of people doing this or that work, and a new variety of bird and animal sounds come through the window. The air is cool and comfortable until we get our blood pumping with the yoga.
I usually take a spot near the side wall in the second row, under the world map. Though the positions are basic, most struggle with them. I don’t struggle the physical stuff, but when it comes to breathing, concentration, and meditation, I may be the worst.
When we’re supposed to close our eyes, I notice mine are very much open:
“Stop staring at Russia,” I scold myself.
My eyes wander around at other people to see who’s wiggling and who’s steady.
I have thoughts like, “There’s no word for the sound of breathing.”
Sometimes I try force myself to concentrate, but it’s like counting sheep: everything goes fine for the first two or three cartoon sheep that make it over the fence, but then one of them finds a patch of grass and misses his turn, then one of your friends comes to sheer sheep number five, and you remember you want to write to that person. Then you remember all the other things you want or need to do and suddenly there’s sheep taking showers, sheep drinking beer, sheep climbing trees, sheep robbing banks – it’s sheep anarchy. But hey, at least I have the moves down.
After faking my way through yoga and breakfast, we return and take our seats for classes. In “culture and civilization,” we have a guest teacher practically every day to lecture us on a topic. On Tuesday, Dr. Rao begins by introducing Dr. Lakshmi Kathacharga, who is teaching the class on “Indian thought and value.”
Dr. Lakshmi sits reclined in a chair in a long white shirt and light pants. A thick red line is painted onto his forehead, running from his hairline to his brow, and two thicker white lines run parallel on either side of the red one. He seems to have the slightest hint of a beer gut.
Before the lecture, Dr. Rao lists off his academic accomplishments in extreme minute detail (this becomes the norm when we have guest teachers; Indians certainly don’t have any problems talking about what they’ve done):
“Dr. Kathacharga has been a professor of the University of Mysore, and at the University of Atlanta, at blah blah university in Switzerland,” Rao begins. “He has served as advisor for the blah blah blah board in Mumbai, and head administrator of the blah blah project. He has created electronic programs to translate Sanskrit into English, studies at 18 different universities and received 25 honorary degrees. He’s been to outer space, created a cure for AIDS, invented a time-travel machine and wrote six New York Times bestselling novels. During the second half of life he…” Minutes later, Dr. Lakshmi thanks Dr. Rao and begins the lecture.
He starts off by explaining what the difference between “systems” (things like computers, cars and the human body) and “users” (the things that make the systems work), and that it is the responsibility of the user to have basic knowledge of the system and provide it with what it needs to work. He also says that if the user dies, the system dies – so that the system depends on the user.
Then he says, as if it were fact, “There are five levels of the human system: the physical body, vital airs, consciousness, the mind/brain, and supreme consciousness that creates, sustains and destroys the whole of the universe.”
“Really?” I think, “This is the foundation in the East for their philosophical beliefs, for their culture, literature, social lives and education? His entire lecture centers around this “truth” the existence of a supreme consciousness.
During my entire college career, my studies have relied on the presumption of the truths of post-structuralism, namely:
- There is no true essence or fixed meaning in things.
- Things only receive meaning when humans impose it on them through the use of an arbitrary language or signifier system.
- There is nothing outside the text.
I’ve never had a strong faith in any supreme being or force, and have been conditioned to be skeptical of supreme consciousness. At first, what he says comes off as ignorant and I’m a little frustrated.
He spends a good deal of time talking about how we must eat only as much as the energy we need to function, we must go to bed at a specific time and wake up at one too, we should sleep on our right side of our bodies, and we should never have attachment to anything, because attachment leads to wastefulness (give me a breaks). And that we must see every person as yourself, and then there would be no crime, harm, or terrorism.
I begin to realize that, whoa, the entire world doesn’t think like Westerners and that school in the East (at least here and I’m assuming other places – I’d love to hear your experiences with this) is taught with a foundation based on faith and spirituality, not skepticism and spiritual lack.
While he speaks, I’m looking at this lecturer guy, who is definitely a little overweight, and whose cell phone goes off in the middle of the lecture. Then I look at Dr. Rao – he’s asleep in his chair and remains that way for at least half the lecture.
“Who are they kidding?” I think to myself. “If you’re going to preach, you should at least practice it.” His value system seems to be more of a theory than a practice.
But then, when I think about it in other ways (my mind has a tendency to play devil’s advocate with itself), some of what he says does seem to make a lot of sense, including:
“Now there is much more mental illness because the questions of purpose and spirituality are not being fulfilled,” he explains, “We are being cluttered by things that cannot fulfill our spiritual desires and needs.”
This really strikes me and I begin to think about the idea. I wrote in a previous post (wonderful/terrible part II), “Nobody really knows why we are all so bipolar now, except that it is very, very specifically human.”
Maybe it isn’t specifically human. It’s specifically Western, postmodern, existential. Is the reason we are so (self) destructive because we lack something essential – faith. Is my existential conditioning the cause of my freak outs and violence behavior? Or is it that humans are simply as naturally violent as they are good, and violence shouldn't be repressed at all? I scribble down a long list of questions his words bring to mind.
Are we too jaded?
Have we gotten to smart for our own good?
Why can’t I focus during yoga?
After class I approach the Dr. I ask him, how he thinks post-structuralist thought affects the lives of westerners; if he think it causes any problems.
"Sorry, I've never heard of this post-structuralism," he replies. "I don't know about everything."
He's never even heard of it. This sort of blows my mind...
For about a second...
then I think...
Oh screw it.
I want to live and not think about these things. I just want to be able to have fun and not care. I want to act based on what feels right. This is all the philosophical bullshit I decided I’d never think about again because it always leads to frustration and unanswered questions. But time and time again, I find myself here and it always makes me depressed until I shut it off again. I just can’t deal.
After class we all go to lunch. The cooks have prepared a typical meal of many options: some sort of rice dish, a salad-like thing, fruit, a veggie dish, paneer, Indian breads, multiple sauces. We fill our plates and dig in. A large electric bug zapper on the ceiling periodically makes sizzling sounds as it kills mosquitoes and flies.
“I’m starving!”
“me too!”
One of the students mentions a bar/club they heard about called High Octane. Another talks about one called Grandpa’s. Supposedly, these are places that cater to international students, selling all sorts of beer and liquor. Most of us can’t wait to go out and have a little fun. We aren’t thinking about the lecture anymore, or the man’s way of life. It was just another lecture like so many we’ve had in our academic careers - just interesting words.
But I’m willing to bet, sooner or later when we're freaking out the most, the big questions will burrow back into our minds.
Sunday, August 19, 2007
Morning Work



The sun creeps into the sky as I get out of bed around 5 a.m. (damn jetlag prevents me from sleeping in). I pull open my curtains and peer out the window at a home in the line of small houses feet away. The lights are already on inside. I cannot see the girl who owns the slightly off-pitch voice. Her songs mix with the morning air and find their way to my room. In a few minutes, a woman in a pink sari, flowers tied to her hair comes out to clean linens in the small backyard.
I have uncomfortably large amount of energy so I play the Girl Talk album and dance around my room for a bit. I try to play it low but wonder if the girl singing in the other house hears it - and whether she closes her ears to the odd recording or listens with interest. I wonder if there are any passersby who hear both our songs together.
Even though it’s early and I’m alone, I decide to go for a walk through the village. The cook for the institute is awake and greets me as I go.
“Good morning. Where are you going?” he asks
“Morning. Just for a walk,” I reply with a smile. He smiles back and continues to the kitchen, taking off his shoes before entering.
The streets aren’t as crowded as later in the day, but there is already a steady bustle. Some of the homes reverberate music into the town. Many of the shops are already open and the others are being set up by shop keepers. Men walk with cattle and goats. Stray wonder dogs walk alone or in packs in the road.
I think about how this is everyday life - not just the actions of it, but the meaning of it. The woman next door wakes up at dawn, when the temperature is coolest and the world is calmest. She begins her daily chores. I wonder what makes the town tick; I wonder where the meaning in their lives is. I am fairly certain it is powerful and extremely fulfilling, although I cannot understand what it is.
Religion? Family? Love? whatever it is, it is definitely not money, power, glamour or celebrity, or material goods. They don’t want or need what we think we want and need. What do they do for fun?
As I walk, a young woman leaves her house. She stands in the small field of wild grasses and stretches. Then large sun rises slowly in the background and I think, this is everyday life. This is my everyday life, this is her everyday life. I wish I could jump into her head for a little while.
I buy a bottle of water then head back (I don’t walk too long because feel slightly awkward walking in the town, like I am being judged for my skin, for my clothes, for my lifestyle. Do they blame me for something?) I pass three men taking advantage of the crispness of the morning, playing a game of badminton. They are having a good time and I suddenly miss toys – Frisbees, hackie sacks, skateboards. I feel like asking them to join, but I know that would be wrong. I feel really detached from this place – very much an outsider and an observer. And do women even play sports here?
At the institute I find a place in the courtyard under a palm tree to review some Hindi I learned during the semester I took it at school. It’s cool out and calm and I think this must be the best time of the day here – the daily rebirth. A few people work in the yard, which is thickly grown with plants.
But I’m quickly distracted by rustling high above in a palm tree, followed by loud smacks from falling coconuts. I look and there’s a man up there swinging a machete at the trees. The man is wearing shorts, no shirt and a wrap around his hair. He has the most perfectly formed body I think I have ever seen – thick arms, small waste, virtually fatless, lots of muscles, which is an obvious result of the kind of work he does.
He climbs silently, effortlessly and extremely quickly, gripping the tree trunk with his hands, shooting both feet up under his thighs like a tree frog, then extending his body straight and doing it again. We swings the machete, letting lose a large cluster green or brown coconuts. After chopping off one tree’s seeds, he proceeds to the next. He does this for dozens of trees in the yard, never showing any sign of fatigue.
As he climbs trees closer and closer to were I sit, the coconuts plummet and bounce closer and closer to me. He has no regard for my presence, which he shouldn’t. He’s the one who has a job to do. When they bounce up to my feet I fear being pummeled by them and move my seat to under the porch of the institute. Still, the falling orbs reach me. I move to the second floor balcony.
I switch my attention back and forth from my studies to the man’s acrobatic show. For a minute I feel compelled to give his task a shot myself. Then I realize the dangers and the skill needed, which I certainly do not have. Again I feel a great divide. Here I am, with my books and my leisure and there he is, hard at probably the most physical kind of work I’ve ever witnessed. I do not have to participate in this kind of work, or much physical daily work at all. The book I hold feels like a luxury. Lots of things feel like luxuries. But then, I do not make judgments on myself or the coconut harvester, or anyone else. We are different, but not opposites. I feel strongly there is no right or wrong way to live, no real cultural hierarchy – and their shouldn’t be a perceive hierarchy either. I wonder, if we communicated, how much we would have in common and how much we would learn.
Soon I’m joined by more students. We watch the worker with great interests. Misty, a student who brought her seven-year-old daughter along, tells me about all the physical health hazards (aside from the obvious one) involved in his work. Jeremy’s son collects a few and lines them up.
“Mine! They’re all mine!” he yells playfully.
A man comes with a large basket to collect them too.
Another student convinces the chef to show her how to open them up, drain them and eat the flesh.
People are close together.
People are far apart.
People are close and far.
There is now music coming from multiple directions. It is the music of the work of morning, calm and appreciative. All the sounds are not in tune. Not all of them are well-trained. But the air holds all of them, and sets them upon all the ears. It swirls them together so that the beat of one song sounds smoothly behind the melody of another, and there is no self-consciousness to the morning song, only a hum for the entire community to share for these earliest hours.
Interview with Bruce Smith
This summer, and since I've been in India, I've gotten away from writing poetry. This has been troubling me. I have little to nothing authentic in it. Everything I wrote seemed forced and immature. Poetry began to become, instead of a way to reveal truths, a way to simply make the world seem pretty, even when it's not. Poetry simply lost its importance to me.
But I've been trying really really hard to find the meaning of it, and remember why I used to call poetry my bible. I need to understand the life in it again, and the realness. I need to find the beats and rhythms that pulse through it like they pulse through the world. I need to connect more in general in order to connect again with poetry.
Riffling through cluttered files on my computer, I found an interview I conducted last spring for Verbal Seduction literary magazine, with poet Bruce Smith. I read over it again. It seems like he never ever lost hold of poetry's importance. His enthusiasm will help me find it. Here's what he said:
Seduced by Bruce
Bruce Smith has had as many concussions as has published books of poetry. He’s a former college football and baseball superstar who’s not afraid to be called “feminine” He thinks you could learn something by going to jail and knows more about rap music than you probably ever will. Soon Bruce Smith will be also add “novelist” to his Résumé.
Smith, a Syracuse University creative writing department poet, is the author of five celebrated books of poems including Songs for Two Voices (University of Chicago, 2005) and The Other Lover (University of Chicago, 2000). The Other Lover was a finalist for the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize. His work has been featured in a diverse spectrum of literary publications including Poetry, Ploughshares, and The American Poetry Review, among many others. His essays and reviews appeared in Harvard Review, Newsday, and Boston Review.. He has received a Guggenheim fellowship as well as other prestigious grants and awards.
Smith spilled it to Verbal Seduction about everything form the challenges of writing a novel, trends in today’s poetry and poets, and why he just can stop putting the bop in the bop-shu-bop.
Interviewer: Becca Fish
Verbal Seduction: So You’ve had a lot of jobs in the past. You played various sports, and worked in a jail. Were you a poet through all of that?
Bruce Smith: No! No. I went to college on a football scholarship in another life— in another time— when I weighed a lot more. I was interested in reading kind of secretly and privately.
VS: Why secretly?
BS: Because my persona was, I was a scholarship athlete. I had to be a football player or a baseball player. That’s really stupid, dumb as a stick kind of attitude. I thought I was going to at least end up playing professional baseball. But I read. I think because my father read. My father was an elementary school teacher. He had a reading life. So thank God there was reading.
VS: What made you become more public of your love for literature?
BS: I stopped playing football after five concussions. I keep reading about people who get dementia from concussions. If I drift off that’s what’s happening (laughter). I stopped and you know the big politicizing important experience for me was: I stopped playing ball and I started to work at the Federal penitentiary. I graduated — I was actually supposed to be doing something with football but instead I worked at the penitentiary in Lewisburg and I taught school there. And that was the big dramatic change for me. It was a really interesting time. It was the late ‘60s early ‘70s it was a time of political unrest with Vietnam. There were some really interesting people in the jail where I was working, like the Barragans, who were from Syracuse, New York — who poured blood on the draft files and they were in jail. I was like, “How can you be in jail?” So the whole political experience was there for me. It was great. Everybody should go in jail I think I’m saying. Everybody in Syracuse. You graduate and spend three years in jail.
VS: Are you giving us permission to commit crime?
BS: (Laughter) Do a crime. Do a major curb Felony. Go to federal jail, don’t go to state jail. State jail’s not that much fun. Then I went to graduate school after that.
VS: Your poetry is very, very musical. You really pay attention to the sound and the rhythm and the beat. I picture you walking around just hearing beats in cars passing and people’s conversations.
BS: You know it’s like that. People who are writing songs, they talk about this too. Is it the beats or is it the lyrics? Are you spinning your lyrics or are you making beats? The Beatles have the same argument. Shakespeare has the same argument. It’s interesting to me what happens when you throw yourself over to music. In other words, writing not out of essential the intellect or quote knowledge of education. But throwing yourself over there. Because I think something else happens. It puts the language in a certain, it puts it under certain pressures. There are often sort of unconscious things. It’s similar to the 1950s, who put the bop in the bop shu-bop-shu bop. Or you know, one example would be — I like the roots. Do you know The Roots from Philadelphia? I love the snare drum. It’s very simple but compelling.
VS: When your writing, what comes first for you? Music or words?
BS: Often I have a bedububu dububu dububu dudu. Sometimes it’s like jazz, like a musical phrase. It’s not far from Frost’s idea. He says that poetry starts with a heartsickness, a homesickness, and then the thought finds feeling and then the feelings find words. So words are actually pretty far down in the process. Sometimes it starts just with a pang or a feeling. I think if you think in words, your listening, I was listening to an old cassette I found on the floor of my car. I think it was Ice Cube singing, “Call up my homeys and I’m asking ya all, what court y’all playing basketball?” I thought, “Oh yeah, that’s fantastic triple rhyme.” So it’s words but it’s also kind of an interesting phrasing.
VS: How are you incorporating this musicality in your novel?
BS: Wait! Novel? What novel? You’re not supposed to know about any novel. Well it’s about music it’s a lot about music. It’s about how the music enters your life in various ways. It’s about how memory is connected to music. When you hear music from 10 years ago you have a very vivid memory. You get to locate yourself instead of being very ethereal and dreamy, like music’s supposed to be, it’s often very located and particular and embodied. It’s about a woman who tries to make sense of male culture really— but music is a big part of it.
VS: Could you talk a little more about your novel?
BS: I was trying to think of a medium to address what I thought was an interesting historical moment, which is just after the ‘60s. Nixon is reelected in ’72. I thought, how do you talk about that? I sort of came up with this woman. She’s going to tell her story. It’s the beginning of feminism the promise of the ‘60s, the conflict of the kind of interesting conflicts of male and female culture, alternative culture. It’s typified with anti-war culture. And at the same time, Nixon got reelected! People forget. The majority of American voters put this guy, who becomes the parody of paranoid politics as opposed to statesmanship, into power. And also in the book, not only music but race. The burden of race.
VS: Speaking of women in male culture, another thing people say about your work all the time is your speakers have very feminine voices, and you use a very feminine tone.
BS: You can be receptive as well. There’s the stereotype of the male writer as the kind of maker — the master. But I think there’s equally interesting image of someone who receives. And maybe that’s what it means to become a woman. To become receptive. I believe that poetry is gendered and raced. But I think the great mind is androgynous. As an aesthetic you want a female and male sensibility. It’s not like I’m trying to speak for women. The novelist Milan Kundera said that “women are my unrealized possibilities.” To try to be conscious of both — it’s kind of the job of the poet. To be receiving is one way I look at it. The way the radio, it’s the most amazing contemporary miracle. Like to be able to receive in that way- the different frequencies. That runs throughout the novel she’s always listening to the radio. The poet should get ABC, NBC, CBS, but the poet should get all those other frequencies too. That’s the job of poetry to speak in those frequencies.
VS: Was it difficult to transition from writing poetry to writing a novel?
BS: I found out after that I’m not a novelist. It’s a good way of looking at your limitations. As we speak I don’t like to talk about it. It hardly exists. It will. I think it was something— I learned something. I think the poet works with line and phrase and music and then to write with like a longer form— I was hitting myself over the head all the time. I found it really paralyzing. Not that I won’t try again. There’s so many words. My way was sort of one sentence after another. That’s terrible. I’m just trying to chomp out a sentence. Then I’m worried about sound, word placement. And then stuff like character and plot, whatever the hell that is.
VS: Did you start to write poetry while working at the jail?
BS: Yeah, kind of. But no. A little bit after that. Not until I got out of graduate school did I really write, because I was really going to go for a straight PhD in English. I was interested in poetry but not to write it so much. But to read it. Because I thoughts that’s how you did it. I tell this to the graduate students. You have 10 years of an apprenticeship. You’re in the middle of your apprenticeship now. You’re writing, You’re reading Williams. You’re writing like Williams. You write a really linear poem. You write like Frank O’Hara, you write like Marianne Moore, You write like, you know, Sylvia Plath. My apprenticeship started at the jail. And then school. I was reading and I was reading, but sooner or later…Saul Bellows says writers are readers moved to emulation. But sooner or later, you read, you read you read, then you say, “Oh, I’m going to try writing a Frank O’Hara Poem. I can do that.”
Plus, Frank O’Hara was like important because I was in New York. Frank O’Hara’s is writing all this New York stuff. I thought, “Oh, he’s the guy.” You must have somebody like that too. There’s the people you have to read for school and then the people you go home and you say, “Oh I really love Frank O’Hara. He’s the guy!” You’re not in school now you can read frank O’Hara and you can write like him! You don’t wave to write like Keats. You don’t have to write like Tennyson. Literature wasn’t just a museum piece. It wasn’t just like, bow down to the great masters. And the Beats were that way too. And then later, because like the idiot I am. Then I found like about Dickenson.
VS: How did you begin to get your poems published?
BS: Well, I started with my friend Peter Balakian, who happens to be a poet and a teacher at Colgate. We started a literary magazine. a magazine called Graham House Review - the Verbal Seduction of North Jersey. He was already writing poetry. He had like a poetry hat. He was like a poet. We started a magazine out of our love for contemporary poets. It was an interesting access to the world of small press and publishing. As we got involved in that, it was like this: You’d open a book of somebody you admire and you would see the places that they published. And you say “I’m going to try that. I’m going to send out.” And that’s kind of how it works you get no, no, no, rejection, rejection, and then somebody says “oh not bad.” It’s still a rejection but you feel encouraged. You know, I think it’s a lot of just persevering, and trying, and failing, and reading, and writing, reading as a kind of prayer too. Then you send out. Then you get a couple poems published. Then you have a bunch of poems together and you have your pitiful manuscript and you send it out. Does that sound too corny?
VS: No! One thing, that sort of relates to that, I feel like most young poets, or aspiring poets see the becoming a professional poet as sort of an elite, unachievable goal. It’s very intimidating. What would you say to them?
BS: Everybody starts as a non-elite. I always think of Dickenson in these cases where she said, “Publication is the auction of the mind.” I kind of think it’s more important to enter the whole dance of it rather than to look to have the poems published. Because I think you can be really damaged by having a really shitty poem published, and be rewarded for your early efforts. You can probably fine ‘zines and online places that are going to publish your work, I’m not saying anything bad about Verbal Seduction, but the publication alone doesn’t really mean anything.
What’s meaningful to me is — call it the dance. The kind of engagement you do with the a tradition. You read the traditional stuff. I do it every summer. For me at least it’s some gap in my own reading. It’s usually something older that I haven’t sufficiently read. It it’s like Homer or Ovid, something like that. And then you read other stuff. Because the other stuff keeps coming to my attentions. Graduate students are always coming and saying, ”Have you read the work of Cole Swenson?” And I said I really don’t know Cole Swenson. I have to read. So that’s the contemporary stuff. That’s what I love about this work. I’m always a perpetual student. There’s Silver Jews on one hand and there’s Ovid on the other. I think for me that’s the exciting, engaging part of it. part of it…that dance.
And Rumi says don’t always window shop. This is what I would say to younger poets: its one thing to go to the bookstore and look and see what’s there in the poetry section and open the magazines, but you should buy something. And also, Latin American Poets, and you know the Chinese poets That’s really helpful. You’re not reading just to confirm some kind of sensibility that you have. Because I know, my undergraduates they just want to read Bukowski. When you’re 18, it’s all about Bukowski. My job is to put Bukowski in his position. They think Bukowski’s it. I’m not slamming him entirely. Some people use his as access to poetry, in the same way of slams, too. And the same way in academic poetry! As long as it doesn’t exclude spoken word, and the blues — hip hop and all that.
VS: If you could take any poet from a past era, and bring him or her back here to write poetry about this social and historical context, who would be the best and most important poet to write about our time?
BS: Oh Man, I think I’d probably go with — I just had like four different thoughts I’ll limit it to two. I’m thinking Roman because I’m thinking with the Bush administration and the empire it would be interesting to have the critique of empire as some of the roman poets did. I think either Horace or Juvenal. Juvenal who like rages against it, and Horace who had a more temperate and sweet disposition. And of course, right away I think of Anna Akhmatova, the Russian poet whose own experience was in going through some extremity and some depravity in her own life. She’s the one who would be great to have because she’s the one who has sort of a consciousness of personal as well as historical memory of this time of Bush— of hostility to humanity, which seems to be characteristic of the last seven years of the Bush administration.
VS: You write a lot about your family, or not yours, but the speakers in your poems talk about speakers and father’s or not. And I’m not going to ask you if those are your family or
BS: See they’re dead people now. So I don’t have to worry about that. But it’s always sort of a risk. When My mom died she had a copy of my book right there. But it was wrapped in plastic. She was proud of the fact that I wrote a book, but she hadn’t read it. It wasn’t there in that way. So I think that was…
VS: A blessing in disguise, maybe
BS: (Laughter) Yeah. Because she was both proud of the fact that I would do something like book. But then bewildered by, or saddened by what she thought was— I go, “You know I’m a poet, I make stuff up.” And she say, “well I don’t know.”
So I think the umbilical stuff is interesting. But I’m actually kind of stepping away from that a little bit. I just feel like, I just don’t want to be writing what I call “adult children of parents” poems. You know how like there’s adult children of alcoholics? Adult children of parents. I don’t just want to be writing those “dear old Dad, dear old Mom” poems. Although I think it’s important to get into that mud.
Of Course you’re born into a historical and an emotional concept. You’re parents you know, what were they thinking? Imagine you’re born into the Bush family. That’s different. To conceive of what that was is to kind of look at. I’m thinking my parents came back after what must have been an unbelievable trauma of the second World War, you know, and they thought they were going to have a kid then? They must have been optimistic in some ways, even thought my father was shell-shocked. That’s an interesting kind of idea, what that means Why would you bring a kid into the world after the world…Sophocles showed us that makes a lot of interesting art, to go back and hit that stuff. All the formative stuff is really interesting to me. Especially for Americans too. They have no Past. Yesterday they think about Roberto Gonzales. Tomorrow we think about Anna Nicole Smith. The Continuity of history…
VS: It’s fragmented.
Yeah, yeah. As opposed to like eastern History. Sense of place too. It always feels like Philadelphia, even though you want to escape it, keeps reappearing in some way as both a place to escape and a place you’re perpetually returning to. It’s kind of like when you come back from college for the first time, and you say, “I’m related to these people? I want to see the DNA evidence.”
VS: When it comes to the industry, Are you happy with it right now?
BS: No! Horrible, contemptible, terrible! (Laughter). I have to say I’m a worker in the industry so in a way I’m criticizing my own endeavor. I mean, if you mean by the industry, mainstream publishing, academia and MFA programs, I have a foot in that. I don’t believe that that’s the God that needs to be worshipped — that’s all there is and that defines what’s good or bad. I don’t think that works. I have a book. It’s a university press. I have a job at a university. I teach in an MFA program. Oh my God! I’m the enemy! (Laughter). And yet I don’t think, as people claim, that there’s a homogenous, academic, workshop style. I look at my own workshop where I’m teaching this course called “Groovin’ Break” about music and I look at the poems and they couldn’t be more diverse. They’re not anything like what I would do. I don’t think you get out there writing an “MFA” poem — what Donald Hall calls a McPoem, like it’s a McDonalds processed — it looks like a workshop poem. I think it’s pretty diverse.
VS: Ok, here’s a silly question. If you were kidnapped by a mad scientist who was going to erase your memory, and would only let you remember one poet, who would it be?
BS: I guess it would be….this is really hard. I guess it has to be “Song of Myself” I’d have to go with Whitman. Because it’s so long. But my next choice would be Dickenson. “My life had stood a loaded gun” of Dickenson’s Those are the two poles for me.. I’d ask for one of those two.
VS: The reason I said it’s a mad scientist who erases your memory, and not a deserted island where you only have one poem is because this way whatever you choose loses all its context.
BS: That’s right. Then I might want to forget that and go with James brown’s live at the Apollo album, where he goes “please, please, please” for about 15 minutes.
VS: In the past there’s been defining aspects of poetic movements, like Modernism or Romanticism. Is there any way to categorize today’s poetry?
BS: You know it’s really tribal. Like if you think of contemporary art— you have installations, you have digital, you have paintings, video. Today’s poetry is kind of like that: very diverse.
VS: If there’s no real way to define it, how can you tell what’s good or not?
BS: I think it’s all interesting. It’s like science. We don’t say of this insect isn’t any good because there’s a jaguar. We say an insect is interesting as well as the jaguar, you know, as well as a jellyfish.. And their all species in the animal kingdom. Poetry is like that too.
And yet you’re interested in that thing— I would call it the “what? Huh.” response. You know, you go “what?” and then you go “huh.” As opposed to the “huh? What?” response. I do think there’s still room for lyricism and beauty, as well as a sort of questioning of language itself. Those are the two poles of contemporary American poetry today. One might be thought of as language poetry, which looks at the materiality of language, versus the kind of the school of quietude that kind of like “I sit down at my computer and look out my window and think about myself” school of poetry. But there’s a big range. I kind of see it as a really active and tribal. And it’s really geographic. The West Coast poets, they feel like they have their own identity. I used to call them the “friends of the rain poets.” It’s more echo awareness than it is maybe in the East Coast. Then there’s the Black Arts Movement. I kind of like the way it shouldn’t be homogenized. I mean, look at America.. If you add in the slam poetry— I think it’s very vital and interesting. You make yourself aware of those different sensibilities.
VS: Do you think there’s room for poetic superstardom in today’s poetry world?
BS: I don’t see that. I don’t see like the great Modernists poets Eliot, Stein or Pound. I think maybe it’s become more democratic in a way. I know there’s some people that complain about that. But then I think we have some. Look at Louise Gluck’s work. I think she’s a rock star to me, and Michael [Burkard] is a rock star in his own humble way because everybody who comes here as a poet says “Oh! Burkard is here. Are you kidding me? He’s great.”
VS: One last question: why does poetry even matter today?
BS: I think it’s like a different frequency. It’s not necessarily the kind of discourse that you get in politics, popular culture or entertainment. It’s some other thing. I think it’s connected with this antiquated notion of the soul. It connects with something that’s very important, maybe even secret that needs to be fed. I think that poetry does that. That’s why poetry sort of appears in funerals and weddings. Our culture doesn’t really have room for it in other ways. It marginalizes it in other ways. But when there’s really crucial, important times for us we’re saying “Oh let’s write a poem for the wedding” and I think that’s an indication of the need for it.
That’s my objection to this slam thing. One place for it is communal and sung and big. And yet there’s also a tradition which is singular, it’s private. It has the ability to pierce you. And then it does make something happen. It changes your life. It changes my life. I’m in the jail and I’m reading poetry and I’m saying “oh my God. I didn’t know you could do this.” The way this stuff spoke to me. You say “Oh my god this has sort of a resonance.” That’s what you hope happens. That’s where poetry’s still essential. You can’t get the news from it, but imagine life without it. The world without music— well look how music is for everybody. It’s important. It’s angelic. Does it have a body at all? Does it even exist. It hardly exists and yet 85 percent of Americans believe in angels. It’s some sort of nonexistence existence that we believe in. I have access now to enter into a place through the imagination that I didn’t before.
But I've been trying really really hard to find the meaning of it, and remember why I used to call poetry my bible. I need to understand the life in it again, and the realness. I need to find the beats and rhythms that pulse through it like they pulse through the world. I need to connect more in general in order to connect again with poetry.
Riffling through cluttered files on my computer, I found an interview I conducted last spring for Verbal Seduction literary magazine, with poet Bruce Smith. I read over it again. It seems like he never ever lost hold of poetry's importance. His enthusiasm will help me find it. Here's what he said:
Seduced by Bruce
Bruce Smith has had as many concussions as has published books of poetry. He’s a former college football and baseball superstar who’s not afraid to be called “feminine” He thinks you could learn something by going to jail and knows more about rap music than you probably ever will. Soon Bruce Smith will be also add “novelist” to his Résumé.
Smith, a Syracuse University creative writing department poet, is the author of five celebrated books of poems including Songs for Two Voices (University of Chicago, 2005) and The Other Lover (University of Chicago, 2000). The Other Lover was a finalist for the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize. His work has been featured in a diverse spectrum of literary publications including Poetry, Ploughshares, and The American Poetry Review, among many others. His essays and reviews appeared in Harvard Review, Newsday, and Boston Review.. He has received a Guggenheim fellowship as well as other prestigious grants and awards.
Smith spilled it to Verbal Seduction about everything form the challenges of writing a novel, trends in today’s poetry and poets, and why he just can stop putting the bop in the bop-shu-bop.
Interviewer: Becca Fish
Verbal Seduction: So You’ve had a lot of jobs in the past. You played various sports, and worked in a jail. Were you a poet through all of that?
Bruce Smith: No! No. I went to college on a football scholarship in another life— in another time— when I weighed a lot more. I was interested in reading kind of secretly and privately.
VS: Why secretly?
BS: Because my persona was, I was a scholarship athlete. I had to be a football player or a baseball player. That’s really stupid, dumb as a stick kind of attitude. I thought I was going to at least end up playing professional baseball. But I read. I think because my father read. My father was an elementary school teacher. He had a reading life. So thank God there was reading.
VS: What made you become more public of your love for literature?
BS: I stopped playing football after five concussions. I keep reading about people who get dementia from concussions. If I drift off that’s what’s happening (laughter). I stopped and you know the big politicizing important experience for me was: I stopped playing ball and I started to work at the Federal penitentiary. I graduated — I was actually supposed to be doing something with football but instead I worked at the penitentiary in Lewisburg and I taught school there. And that was the big dramatic change for me. It was a really interesting time. It was the late ‘60s early ‘70s it was a time of political unrest with Vietnam. There were some really interesting people in the jail where I was working, like the Barragans, who were from Syracuse, New York — who poured blood on the draft files and they were in jail. I was like, “How can you be in jail?” So the whole political experience was there for me. It was great. Everybody should go in jail I think I’m saying. Everybody in Syracuse. You graduate and spend three years in jail.
VS: Are you giving us permission to commit crime?
BS: (Laughter) Do a crime. Do a major curb Felony. Go to federal jail, don’t go to state jail. State jail’s not that much fun. Then I went to graduate school after that.
VS: Your poetry is very, very musical. You really pay attention to the sound and the rhythm and the beat. I picture you walking around just hearing beats in cars passing and people’s conversations.
BS: You know it’s like that. People who are writing songs, they talk about this too. Is it the beats or is it the lyrics? Are you spinning your lyrics or are you making beats? The Beatles have the same argument. Shakespeare has the same argument. It’s interesting to me what happens when you throw yourself over to music. In other words, writing not out of essential the intellect or quote knowledge of education. But throwing yourself over there. Because I think something else happens. It puts the language in a certain, it puts it under certain pressures. There are often sort of unconscious things. It’s similar to the 1950s, who put the bop in the bop shu-bop-shu bop. Or you know, one example would be — I like the roots. Do you know The Roots from Philadelphia? I love the snare drum. It’s very simple but compelling.
VS: When your writing, what comes first for you? Music or words?
BS: Often I have a bedububu dububu dububu dudu. Sometimes it’s like jazz, like a musical phrase. It’s not far from Frost’s idea. He says that poetry starts with a heartsickness, a homesickness, and then the thought finds feeling and then the feelings find words. So words are actually pretty far down in the process. Sometimes it starts just with a pang or a feeling. I think if you think in words, your listening, I was listening to an old cassette I found on the floor of my car. I think it was Ice Cube singing, “Call up my homeys and I’m asking ya all, what court y’all playing basketball?” I thought, “Oh yeah, that’s fantastic triple rhyme.” So it’s words but it’s also kind of an interesting phrasing.
VS: How are you incorporating this musicality in your novel?
BS: Wait! Novel? What novel? You’re not supposed to know about any novel. Well it’s about music it’s a lot about music. It’s about how the music enters your life in various ways. It’s about how memory is connected to music. When you hear music from 10 years ago you have a very vivid memory. You get to locate yourself instead of being very ethereal and dreamy, like music’s supposed to be, it’s often very located and particular and embodied. It’s about a woman who tries to make sense of male culture really— but music is a big part of it.
VS: Could you talk a little more about your novel?
BS: I was trying to think of a medium to address what I thought was an interesting historical moment, which is just after the ‘60s. Nixon is reelected in ’72. I thought, how do you talk about that? I sort of came up with this woman. She’s going to tell her story. It’s the beginning of feminism the promise of the ‘60s, the conflict of the kind of interesting conflicts of male and female culture, alternative culture. It’s typified with anti-war culture. And at the same time, Nixon got reelected! People forget. The majority of American voters put this guy, who becomes the parody of paranoid politics as opposed to statesmanship, into power. And also in the book, not only music but race. The burden of race.
VS: Speaking of women in male culture, another thing people say about your work all the time is your speakers have very feminine voices, and you use a very feminine tone.
BS: You can be receptive as well. There’s the stereotype of the male writer as the kind of maker — the master. But I think there’s equally interesting image of someone who receives. And maybe that’s what it means to become a woman. To become receptive. I believe that poetry is gendered and raced. But I think the great mind is androgynous. As an aesthetic you want a female and male sensibility. It’s not like I’m trying to speak for women. The novelist Milan Kundera said that “women are my unrealized possibilities.” To try to be conscious of both — it’s kind of the job of the poet. To be receiving is one way I look at it. The way the radio, it’s the most amazing contemporary miracle. Like to be able to receive in that way- the different frequencies. That runs throughout the novel she’s always listening to the radio. The poet should get ABC, NBC, CBS, but the poet should get all those other frequencies too. That’s the job of poetry to speak in those frequencies.
VS: Was it difficult to transition from writing poetry to writing a novel?
BS: I found out after that I’m not a novelist. It’s a good way of looking at your limitations. As we speak I don’t like to talk about it. It hardly exists. It will. I think it was something— I learned something. I think the poet works with line and phrase and music and then to write with like a longer form— I was hitting myself over the head all the time. I found it really paralyzing. Not that I won’t try again. There’s so many words. My way was sort of one sentence after another. That’s terrible. I’m just trying to chomp out a sentence. Then I’m worried about sound, word placement. And then stuff like character and plot, whatever the hell that is.
VS: Did you start to write poetry while working at the jail?
BS: Yeah, kind of. But no. A little bit after that. Not until I got out of graduate school did I really write, because I was really going to go for a straight PhD in English. I was interested in poetry but not to write it so much. But to read it. Because I thoughts that’s how you did it. I tell this to the graduate students. You have 10 years of an apprenticeship. You’re in the middle of your apprenticeship now. You’re writing, You’re reading Williams. You’re writing like Williams. You write a really linear poem. You write like Frank O’Hara, you write like Marianne Moore, You write like, you know, Sylvia Plath. My apprenticeship started at the jail. And then school. I was reading and I was reading, but sooner or later…Saul Bellows says writers are readers moved to emulation. But sooner or later, you read, you read you read, then you say, “Oh, I’m going to try writing a Frank O’Hara Poem. I can do that.”
Plus, Frank O’Hara was like important because I was in New York. Frank O’Hara’s is writing all this New York stuff. I thought, “Oh, he’s the guy.” You must have somebody like that too. There’s the people you have to read for school and then the people you go home and you say, “Oh I really love Frank O’Hara. He’s the guy!” You’re not in school now you can read frank O’Hara and you can write like him! You don’t wave to write like Keats. You don’t have to write like Tennyson. Literature wasn’t just a museum piece. It wasn’t just like, bow down to the great masters. And the Beats were that way too. And then later, because like the idiot I am. Then I found like about Dickenson.
VS: How did you begin to get your poems published?
BS: Well, I started with my friend Peter Balakian, who happens to be a poet and a teacher at Colgate. We started a literary magazine. a magazine called Graham House Review - the Verbal Seduction of North Jersey. He was already writing poetry. He had like a poetry hat. He was like a poet. We started a magazine out of our love for contemporary poets. It was an interesting access to the world of small press and publishing. As we got involved in that, it was like this: You’d open a book of somebody you admire and you would see the places that they published. And you say “I’m going to try that. I’m going to send out.” And that’s kind of how it works you get no, no, no, rejection, rejection, and then somebody says “oh not bad.” It’s still a rejection but you feel encouraged. You know, I think it’s a lot of just persevering, and trying, and failing, and reading, and writing, reading as a kind of prayer too. Then you send out. Then you get a couple poems published. Then you have a bunch of poems together and you have your pitiful manuscript and you send it out. Does that sound too corny?
VS: No! One thing, that sort of relates to that, I feel like most young poets, or aspiring poets see the becoming a professional poet as sort of an elite, unachievable goal. It’s very intimidating. What would you say to them?
BS: Everybody starts as a non-elite. I always think of Dickenson in these cases where she said, “Publication is the auction of the mind.” I kind of think it’s more important to enter the whole dance of it rather than to look to have the poems published. Because I think you can be really damaged by having a really shitty poem published, and be rewarded for your early efforts. You can probably fine ‘zines and online places that are going to publish your work, I’m not saying anything bad about Verbal Seduction, but the publication alone doesn’t really mean anything.
What’s meaningful to me is — call it the dance. The kind of engagement you do with the a tradition. You read the traditional stuff. I do it every summer. For me at least it’s some gap in my own reading. It’s usually something older that I haven’t sufficiently read. It it’s like Homer or Ovid, something like that. And then you read other stuff. Because the other stuff keeps coming to my attentions. Graduate students are always coming and saying, ”Have you read the work of Cole Swenson?” And I said I really don’t know Cole Swenson. I have to read. So that’s the contemporary stuff. That’s what I love about this work. I’m always a perpetual student. There’s Silver Jews on one hand and there’s Ovid on the other. I think for me that’s the exciting, engaging part of it. part of it…that dance.
And Rumi says don’t always window shop. This is what I would say to younger poets: its one thing to go to the bookstore and look and see what’s there in the poetry section and open the magazines, but you should buy something. And also, Latin American Poets, and you know the Chinese poets That’s really helpful. You’re not reading just to confirm some kind of sensibility that you have. Because I know, my undergraduates they just want to read Bukowski. When you’re 18, it’s all about Bukowski. My job is to put Bukowski in his position. They think Bukowski’s it. I’m not slamming him entirely. Some people use his as access to poetry, in the same way of slams, too. And the same way in academic poetry! As long as it doesn’t exclude spoken word, and the blues — hip hop and all that.
VS: If you could take any poet from a past era, and bring him or her back here to write poetry about this social and historical context, who would be the best and most important poet to write about our time?
BS: Oh Man, I think I’d probably go with — I just had like four different thoughts I’ll limit it to two. I’m thinking Roman because I’m thinking with the Bush administration and the empire it would be interesting to have the critique of empire as some of the roman poets did. I think either Horace or Juvenal. Juvenal who like rages against it, and Horace who had a more temperate and sweet disposition. And of course, right away I think of Anna Akhmatova, the Russian poet whose own experience was in going through some extremity and some depravity in her own life. She’s the one who would be great to have because she’s the one who has sort of a consciousness of personal as well as historical memory of this time of Bush— of hostility to humanity, which seems to be characteristic of the last seven years of the Bush administration.
VS: You write a lot about your family, or not yours, but the speakers in your poems talk about speakers and father’s or not. And I’m not going to ask you if those are your family or
BS: See they’re dead people now. So I don’t have to worry about that. But it’s always sort of a risk. When My mom died she had a copy of my book right there. But it was wrapped in plastic. She was proud of the fact that I wrote a book, but she hadn’t read it. It wasn’t there in that way. So I think that was…
VS: A blessing in disguise, maybe
BS: (Laughter) Yeah. Because she was both proud of the fact that I would do something like book. But then bewildered by, or saddened by what she thought was— I go, “You know I’m a poet, I make stuff up.” And she say, “well I don’t know.”
So I think the umbilical stuff is interesting. But I’m actually kind of stepping away from that a little bit. I just feel like, I just don’t want to be writing what I call “adult children of parents” poems. You know how like there’s adult children of alcoholics? Adult children of parents. I don’t just want to be writing those “dear old Dad, dear old Mom” poems. Although I think it’s important to get into that mud.
Of Course you’re born into a historical and an emotional concept. You’re parents you know, what were they thinking? Imagine you’re born into the Bush family. That’s different. To conceive of what that was is to kind of look at. I’m thinking my parents came back after what must have been an unbelievable trauma of the second World War, you know, and they thought they were going to have a kid then? They must have been optimistic in some ways, even thought my father was shell-shocked. That’s an interesting kind of idea, what that means Why would you bring a kid into the world after the world…Sophocles showed us that makes a lot of interesting art, to go back and hit that stuff. All the formative stuff is really interesting to me. Especially for Americans too. They have no Past. Yesterday they think about Roberto Gonzales. Tomorrow we think about Anna Nicole Smith. The Continuity of history…
VS: It’s fragmented.
Yeah, yeah. As opposed to like eastern History. Sense of place too. It always feels like Philadelphia, even though you want to escape it, keeps reappearing in some way as both a place to escape and a place you’re perpetually returning to. It’s kind of like when you come back from college for the first time, and you say, “I’m related to these people? I want to see the DNA evidence.”
VS: When it comes to the industry, Are you happy with it right now?
BS: No! Horrible, contemptible, terrible! (Laughter). I have to say I’m a worker in the industry so in a way I’m criticizing my own endeavor. I mean, if you mean by the industry, mainstream publishing, academia and MFA programs, I have a foot in that. I don’t believe that that’s the God that needs to be worshipped — that’s all there is and that defines what’s good or bad. I don’t think that works. I have a book. It’s a university press. I have a job at a university. I teach in an MFA program. Oh my God! I’m the enemy! (Laughter). And yet I don’t think, as people claim, that there’s a homogenous, academic, workshop style. I look at my own workshop where I’m teaching this course called “Groovin’ Break” about music and I look at the poems and they couldn’t be more diverse. They’re not anything like what I would do. I don’t think you get out there writing an “MFA” poem — what Donald Hall calls a McPoem, like it’s a McDonalds processed — it looks like a workshop poem. I think it’s pretty diverse.
VS: Ok, here’s a silly question. If you were kidnapped by a mad scientist who was going to erase your memory, and would only let you remember one poet, who would it be?
BS: I guess it would be….this is really hard. I guess it has to be “Song of Myself” I’d have to go with Whitman. Because it’s so long. But my next choice would be Dickenson. “My life had stood a loaded gun” of Dickenson’s Those are the two poles for me.. I’d ask for one of those two.
VS: The reason I said it’s a mad scientist who erases your memory, and not a deserted island where you only have one poem is because this way whatever you choose loses all its context.
BS: That’s right. Then I might want to forget that and go with James brown’s live at the Apollo album, where he goes “please, please, please” for about 15 minutes.
VS: In the past there’s been defining aspects of poetic movements, like Modernism or Romanticism. Is there any way to categorize today’s poetry?
BS: You know it’s really tribal. Like if you think of contemporary art— you have installations, you have digital, you have paintings, video. Today’s poetry is kind of like that: very diverse.
VS: If there’s no real way to define it, how can you tell what’s good or not?
BS: I think it’s all interesting. It’s like science. We don’t say of this insect isn’t any good because there’s a jaguar. We say an insect is interesting as well as the jaguar, you know, as well as a jellyfish.. And their all species in the animal kingdom. Poetry is like that too.
And yet you’re interested in that thing— I would call it the “what? Huh.” response. You know, you go “what?” and then you go “huh.” As opposed to the “huh? What?” response. I do think there’s still room for lyricism and beauty, as well as a sort of questioning of language itself. Those are the two poles of contemporary American poetry today. One might be thought of as language poetry, which looks at the materiality of language, versus the kind of the school of quietude that kind of like “I sit down at my computer and look out my window and think about myself” school of poetry. But there’s a big range. I kind of see it as a really active and tribal. And it’s really geographic. The West Coast poets, they feel like they have their own identity. I used to call them the “friends of the rain poets.” It’s more echo awareness than it is maybe in the East Coast. Then there’s the Black Arts Movement. I kind of like the way it shouldn’t be homogenized. I mean, look at America.. If you add in the slam poetry— I think it’s very vital and interesting. You make yourself aware of those different sensibilities.
VS: Do you think there’s room for poetic superstardom in today’s poetry world?
BS: I don’t see that. I don’t see like the great Modernists poets Eliot, Stein or Pound. I think maybe it’s become more democratic in a way. I know there’s some people that complain about that. But then I think we have some. Look at Louise Gluck’s work. I think she’s a rock star to me, and Michael [Burkard] is a rock star in his own humble way because everybody who comes here as a poet says “Oh! Burkard is here. Are you kidding me? He’s great.”
VS: One last question: why does poetry even matter today?
BS: I think it’s like a different frequency. It’s not necessarily the kind of discourse that you get in politics, popular culture or entertainment. It’s some other thing. I think it’s connected with this antiquated notion of the soul. It connects with something that’s very important, maybe even secret that needs to be fed. I think that poetry does that. That’s why poetry sort of appears in funerals and weddings. Our culture doesn’t really have room for it in other ways. It marginalizes it in other ways. But when there’s really crucial, important times for us we’re saying “Oh let’s write a poem for the wedding” and I think that’s an indication of the need for it.
That’s my objection to this slam thing. One place for it is communal and sung and big. And yet there’s also a tradition which is singular, it’s private. It has the ability to pierce you. And then it does make something happen. It changes your life. It changes my life. I’m in the jail and I’m reading poetry and I’m saying “oh my God. I didn’t know you could do this.” The way this stuff spoke to me. You say “Oh my god this has sort of a resonance.” That’s what you hope happens. That’s where poetry’s still essential. You can’t get the news from it, but imagine life without it. The world without music— well look how music is for everybody. It’s important. It’s angelic. Does it have a body at all? Does it even exist. It hardly exists and yet 85 percent of Americans believe in angels. It’s some sort of nonexistence existence that we believe in. I have access now to enter into a place through the imagination that I didn’t before.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)