The public have an insatiable curiosity to know everything. Except what is worth knowing. Journalism, conscious of this, and having tradesman-like habits, supplies their demands - Oscar Wilde
** This is fictionalized. I wrote it last December. And I really do live all the people here, both professionally and as neighbors.**
Reporting for a small town is one thing. But reporting for the small town you live in is quite another.
One morning about a week after we’ve made the move to Small Town X, I’m walking home after my run. A large green SUV slows then pulls next to me. "Hi neighbor!" I hear a shrill voice call from the driver’s seat. There’s a small boy, a son, riding shotgun with a listless stare. After a minute of adjusting my mind I recognize the chipper woman as L, a member of the school board who I see at every two hours and some minutes Tuesday night school board meeting I’m obligated to sit through and have called a handful of times for stories.
"You live on this street?" I ask her. She points to a light blue house on the corner. Oh no. I’m living in frienemy territory.
Jaye’s voice never changes- the sickly sweet high-pitched tone is so cheery you just know she’s faking. Since L in charge of maybe five town organizations (Friends of the Library, School Board, and the senior center to name a couple). She’s called me up a few times asking me to cover this or that event. “Hiiii. It’s Llll. How are you?” The long, drawn out soprano tones – eek. I’m convinced she actually hates me. How can she not? I’ve written some pretty telling things about the school board. Well, not telling I guess, so much as petty. But that’s the thing, town news is petty. It’s schoolyard gossip – a bunch of people that know each other too well where there’s no line between personal and political. One time Jaye asked me if I think the people of the town are gossipy. I wanted to say yes but instead I just said, “Not really. I think you all want what’s best for the town and people don’t always get along.”
I got this tip from my editor a couple weeks back that because the economy is so bad, there might be more people living in their lake homes, which would affect various town resources and such. I call up the zoning and code enforcer at the town offices to see if there’s a story here. That was a bad idea. “Do you know if there are more people staying year-round in 1akeside property than normal in Hampstead because of the economy?” I ask.
“Why do you know anyone who’s doing that,” the stern woman replies.
“No,” I respond quickly. “I was just curious for a story.”
“If anyone does that we would bring them to court; it’s illegal,” the stern woman snaps. “Are you sure you don’t know anyone who’s doing that? Are you doing that?”
I reply that I’m not, but I’m actually not entirely sure if our cottage is zoned for fulltime or seasonal use so the question is a little bit terrifying. I stick to my guns though- I’m not living illegally in Hampstead and I don’t know anyone who is. Crap.
Days later I see L at some town function I’m covering. She’s her usual overfriendly, can’t decide if she actually hates me, self. “How do you like the house?” She asks. Then, “You know I talked to ---. She told me about your call.”
Jebus, gossip travels faster than light around here.
“You are living on seasonal property,” she says. “But don’t worry. --- is a friend of mine. You just need to leave for a week or something to make it seasonal.”
I swallow hard. Great, now I’m living in a great home on a lovely lake, I’m the town reporter who people generally like having around, but if I piss the right people off inadvertently through a story I write for the paper I could potentially be kicked out of my home (Bottom line it’s my landlords problem, not the innocent renter, but it just looks bad).
I see the headline on the front page of my rival paper’s Sunday addition. It says something like, “Journalist living illegally in town. Residents give the boot.”
And there is plenty of potential to piss these people off because they often do or say things publicly or even on the record by phone, not realizing that I have every right to publish all of that. One time, the loose-lipped and angry firefighter of the town was trying to invent a position that includes a pay raise for one of his men. These sorts of things have to go first to the Board of Selectmen, then to the Wage and Salary committee. The whole process (because even small town government is so inefficient) is painfully slow, often involves people talking about the same thing five times, and goes through a ritual shouting match each meeting. And because this is such tight time financially, anything involving town employee pay raises is the subject of much debate and scrutiny. So when the fire chief tells me things like, “Selectwoman X’s husband left her because she’s such a beast; she doesn’t listen to anything especially when it’s a man who has the problem,” or “I thought New Selectman Y would bring some young blood into the bunch, but he’s just as bad. I call him Herr Wolf.” Orrr…, “It’s not my fault that the whole wage and salary committee is completely incompetent at what they do,” I could technically publish all of this.
Why don’t I? Isn’t that the interesting, juicy stuff that people want to hear about? Well yes…and no. The tricky thing is that the people I write about also tend to be my best sources for stories. So the question is, do I want to write an out of this world, shit your pants story and probably never write another story involving the person I pissed off ever again (and also be subject to a stream of ripped emails and phone calls thus making my living experience hell-on-earthish) or do I dumb down the good story for the sake of maintaining relationships?
Of course I do the latter. I have to. But that’s one problem with the journalism system, especially when the audience is contained and close. They are both my subject and object. I have to play nice with all these frienemies who obviously have their own agenda with me.
I’ve built a persona just for them, too. It’s completely diplomatic and sneaky sometimes. I like to get them on my side. This is very easy because my public disposition is so friendly and approachable. I am completely interested in them. I listen. I want to put their name in print. I want to help them with their platform, their cause, their side of the story. I’m the light to their moth. So they blab their little mouths off.
But the truth is, I don’t really care about them all that much. I mean, I do, it’s my job too and most of them are great, nice people. But bottom line is I cater to my boss and editor. I need to fill the paper with stories no matter what. So these people talking to me are helping me and befriending them (however superficially) helps me get paid. I guess we use each other. Symbiotic agenda meeting. Bridge burning forbidden.
Here’s a strange thing about reporting: I love writing and I want to write everything as good as possible. But when I’m on deadline and overworked and there’s nothing going on in town but a charitable coat drive, the stress is on and I go into survival mode. Screw the art, screw the integrity just fill the damn paper. Think about that.
Another strange thing: advertisers have sway. I guess this is fairly well known. I’m sure you’ve all heard it before. My paper, for instance, will only write a piece about a business if that business advertises with us. And of course, that story has to be cheery and praising of said business.
One day I get this angry email:
Hi Rebecca
Imagine my surprise when reading your article titled "-----" where I am quoted (third party) as telling residents that "if they have a problem with their tax bills to take it to the schools". How can you have written this without ever contacting me to verify the quote?? I did not say this to Jaye or to anyone. In a conversation with Jaye ---- I told her to expect more calls from residents because we are telling concerned tax payers to contact both Boards - the Board of Selectmen and the School Board. A little more tactful than how I am quoted in the paper! I would appreciate a retraction.
Well I’m a professional. So I sent back a professionally generic reaction:
Hi ----,
I'm very sorry to have upset you. I should have double checked with you. We certainly don't like to misinform. Jaye has been a very good, reliable source for me, so I suppose I assumed the information was correct. She said it to me on the phone and at a budget meeting and I didn't have a reason to doubt her. But you are right, I should have contacted you and I'm very sorry. I will be much more careful in the future.
What is my bottom line? First, I was completely in line writing about her because what I quoted someone saying about her was spoken at a public town meeting. Second, I don’t give a rat’s ass about this person, really because she hasn’t done all that much for me. She’s not a high priority source. I’m far more concerned with stirring things up with Jaye. If this angry reader goes to L and says, “Hey, why’d you lie about me to the town reporter?” L could all of a sudden cut me off and one of my most reliable sources goes to ash. Have I indirectly burnt a very important bridge?
What makes this bridge even more important is that we all know L is good friends with the woman who could hypothetically take me to court and sue me for living here. I can hear it now in that chirpy friendly voice of hers.
“Hi Rebecca it’s L,” she’ll squeal. “I’m here to ruin your life.”
1 comment:
I was young and for it seemed absolutely grotesque to me at the time.
Post a Comment