I had the pleasure of reading Neal Gabler's "Life, the Movie" way back as a first year communications student at Newhouse. Last week he came out with an abridged and updated premise to his theories on life, as portrayed through the media, as the ultimate form of entertainment. In other words, movies and books are no longer the best stories, but life itself is.
In hi new Newsweek Article, Gabler makes some bold claims: that art and entertainment are virtually inseparable, that celebrities (not the roles they play in movies) are the greatest form of art/entertainment because their narratives keep us in suspence, teach us about good and bad, morals, ethics, and decision and consequence.
Read the article if you want his entire shpeel. I was interested in his arguments about the marginalization of literature and even film as modes of art and entertainment. It's true films can do things books cannot in terms of action and visual stimulation, which has pushed books into the realm of phychological investigation, and a small niche readership. And perhaps films are even a step removed from what people really want. So in a sense, celebrity narrative does seem to give the people something more identifiable than ever.
But Gabler makes an argument about art. Are celebrity narratives art? Gabler claims they are. I dissagree. What's happening to Brangelina, TIger Woods, or Spencer and Heidi IS NOT ART. Or is it? It's cheap, sensationalism, right? Right?? And Gablers claims that these stories are real because they are performed in a medium of life is also false. They are not real life, but controled action. To say that celebrity gossip is real is to say that Shakespeare performed on stage is real, or any movie. Nothing, no art, can be performed in anything other than real life if you're reductive about it.
Sigh. I don't know.
By the way, R.I.P Brittany Murphy.
Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment