I had the pleasure of reading Neal Gabler's "Life, the Movie" way back as a first year communications student at Newhouse. Last week he came out with an abridged and updated premise to his theories on life, as portrayed through the media, as the ultimate form of entertainment. In other words, movies and books are no longer the best stories, but life itself is.
In hi new Newsweek Article, Gabler makes some bold claims: that art and entertainment are virtually inseparable, that celebrities (not the roles they play in movies) are the greatest form of art/entertainment because their narratives keep us in suspence, teach us about good and bad, morals, ethics, and decision and consequence.
Read the article if you want his entire shpeel. I was interested in his arguments about the marginalization of literature and even film as modes of art and entertainment. It's true films can do things books cannot in terms of action and visual stimulation, which has pushed books into the realm of phychological investigation, and a small niche readership. And perhaps films are even a step removed from what people really want. So in a sense, celebrity narrative does seem to give the people something more identifiable than ever.
But Gabler makes an argument about art. Are celebrity narratives art? Gabler claims they are. I dissagree. What's happening to Brangelina, TIger Woods, or Spencer and Heidi IS NOT ART. Or is it? It's cheap, sensationalism, right? Right?? And Gablers claims that these stories are real because they are performed in a medium of life is also false. They are not real life, but controled action. To say that celebrity gossip is real is to say that Shakespeare performed on stage is real, or any movie. Nothing, no art, can be performed in anything other than real life if you're reductive about it.
Sigh. I don't know.
By the way, R.I.P Brittany Murphy.
Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Friday, December 04, 2009
Last two weeks of the first semester
Okay, well. I have some some solid revisions. I'm looking forward to writing some new stories. I'm going to try sending some work out. It feels like a productive semesters, 1/6 done my MFA experience and I can't complain.
short list of things I've learned about writing:
- Formulaic plot is for genre writing, and though it sells lots of copies, it is not good art. Make some kind of math equation out of that and you get good art is not equal to selling lots of copies.
- If you're writing a fictional story set in the past, feel free to speculate about a famous (or imfamous) person's emotions and motives, but get all the other historical facts right.
- Sometimes the best poetry is collaborative.
- Emily Dickenson poems can be sung to blues melodies and the result is a raunchy pleause.
- Only one person per worshop is allowed to use "skull fucking" in a story.
- Writing is really hard.
- Stressing out makes writing even harder.
-George Saunders may actually be a genious.
- MFAs are not ponzy scams!!!!
Did I mention we got a cat? An ex-stray or feral cat. His name is Harvey and he'll eat anything in his path due to so many months looking out for himself.
I feel like I should put something substative here. I'm not going to just now. I have been doing a lot of thinking about writing and viwing the world in general, and I've been writing it down in lots of ways, paper journals, stories, conversations, etc. I don't have the energy to do it here right now.
I've been killing a bunch of time hitting the "next blog" button on the top of the blogger page because now they're doing this thing where it sends you to similar blogs. I've wasted so much time looking at the blogs of writers. It's a double edged sword.
When if comes to Obama's Afghanistan decision, I'm trying not to be bias because I have a sister who might be sent overseas for a forth time. Shit like that never happened before. It really is madness. Also, if there's a war tax like the Democrats are proposing, I propose no one who's got family in the military should have to pay it. That's doing double duty.
So, I think I'll be in NYC Dec. 8 - 10 and maybe longer. Holla?
Monday, November 16, 2009
The beasts
What to say, what to say?
An undergrad died the other day. R.I.P Lisa Crowely. I didn't know you, but I ache for you. I wonder what it's like. The D.O. reported police says it's suicide. I found her on Facebook and she's so beautiful and happy looking. Big smiles. Big, big smiles. It's hard to imagine a person looking like they embrace life fully would deprive herself like that. But then, that's what some people do. They smile and smile and smile because they do not want to put their burden on someone else's back. Or they want to put it on the right person's back, the person who sees through the mask and reaches out. Most people just don't see, though. They want to be fooled. That's a true story.
Writing's got me miffed. My language/lines keep getting stronger, but I'm stressing too much. I'm either too far or too close to reality and that's a problem. I had this idea the other day that as long as a writer knows what he wants to say the story can be anything as long as it says that. So, there's a lot of freedom.
It's been a stressfest lately and not fun, and if writing should be anything, it should be fun. You're inventing. You're going wherever you want to go. Sometimes I feel the things that matter to me, that I'd like to write about just won't translate in the end - either feel melodramatic or depressing or big-questiony. I guess I just have to go for it and not worry about the meaning, or whether or not I'm too close to home, or whether or not there are more important ways to spend my time. I guess that question depends on what I'm writing about.
I survived my first reading. i stressed out all week trying to find something suitable and I don't think I succeeded, I don't think I represented my mind right, but reading through my work, nothing did. Which I guess is the problem and frustration of a young writer- having all these things to say and not yet knowing how best to say them. Voice, voice, voice. That's all I've been thinking about. You have nothing if you don't have voice to communicate.
Stress, stress, stress, stresssss. I used that word about a thousand times just then. Some one help me remember how to be here now. this is stupid.
What else?
what else?
I've been having frequent dreams of people in my past. Sleep, don't be such a bother and a tease.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
A walk in the Cuse
G and I had a moment to breathe together so we walked up to the water tower top of Thordon Park, the massive one hill that overlooks all of Syracuse, to look for the red church.
We were going to have a vacation in Syracuse, G's idea.
I said, "I think we should have a mini vacation."
"A mini-vacation?" he asked.
"Yeah, just for the weekend."
"But I have to work."
"You can take a weekend off."
"I think we should have your vacations in Syracuse. Going places is expensive."
"True."
"We can find ways to have fun here. You don't have to go away to get away from work, right?"
"That's true."
Oh G, always the logical one.
Full blown autumn now, the landscape is a long expanse of orange, yellow and red. We found the red church out in the distance, though it didn't stand out nearly as much as it did in the summer, surrounded by green. We planned our route to get to it, going north through multiple neighborhood and underneath the high way.
It's been warm these past few days. We remembered the beginning of October, into the thrities at night and people began putting their heat on. There's been no need for that lately. It was perfect walling weather. There was even some blue sky peaking though the massive, constant clouds.
As we walked, it became so clear how quickly neighborhoods change. First it was ours, the small town-feely, semi-artsy neighborhood by the university. It's populated with young families, professors and students. These are people who hand Halloween decorations on their houses and throw frisbees in the street. People with massive overgrown front gardens that hide the sidwalk and boast signs that say "pesicide free garden." Walk a little further, down around E. Genessee street and Fayetteville road and things get shabby fast. Here the houses are broken down, porches coming to pieces, paint chipping, broken front steps. Many of the houses aren't even used. It stays that way until you cross the highway. In front of one particularly shabby house, trash all over the dirt in front of it, porch broken to pieces, a gangle of children played outside with broken toys.
"How do you think that childhood would be?"
"Terrible."
The church was on the base of a park. We got there right at six, when the bells were just ringing. It wasn't nearly as impressive up close. Just a plain red brick building with a steeple. I tried the doors but they were locked.
We decided to walk up the rest of the hill, which turned out to be another park. It reminded me of some parks in Luxembourg, steep stone saircases cutting through a heavily wooded ground leading to open grassy spaces at different levels.
"I wonder if the cops come up here at night?"
"Maybe. You'd think they might be more interested in stuff going down where people live, like burglaries and people smashing windows."
"Yeah, but a lot of vandalism happens in parks. And they have to worry about drug deals and stuff. I wonder if cops wouldn't even come to a placelike this because it's too dangerous."
G tells me about a place in France that was largely known to be off limits at night.
"I walked around some pretty sketchy places near there," he said.
"I feel like I've spent a lot of my life not being afraid of things I probably should have been afriad of," I said.
"I've spent most of my it too afraid of places I probably shouldn't have. It's better not to be."
"Maybe."
We walk to the top of the park. It's a circular drive with another view over Syacuse. We're the only two people there.
All except for what a mother, a grandmother, and two young children taking pictures of one another and the scenery. The kids climp on rocks and walk with the adults. They seem more wary of us than we are of them. All the talk about danger and it couldn't be more normal.
And why is it we are so quick to look for differences and so easily ignore the way's we are the same?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)