**Note** By my next post the name of my blog will have changed for "professional" reasons. I'm not for censorship, but some people seem to think it would be in my best interest to change it, and they are probably right. I'm open to suggestions for a new name.**
I’m hanging out with Allison in the dining room at about 11:30 Sunday night. She’s studying Sanskrit and I’m drinking water, waiting for Jason to finish his phone call with his mom so we can continue working on the guitar song we’re creating.
Suddenly, George, one of the two students from Germany studying Kannada, runs into the dining room.
“I’ve lost Alex and Annika!” He blurts. He’s panting and his face is covered in beads of sweat. Alex is a really cool guy from University of Iowa, who has a shown a tendency to get a little too drunk for his own good now and then. Annika came from Germany with George.
After we realize he’s serious, Allison and I spend a couple minutes trying to get the details of what George said.
“We were leaving the bar and these two guys on motorbikes offer to give us a ride home. So me Alex get on one bike and Annika gets on the other. We got dropped off down the road. But he took Annika somewhere else!
“Alex was really drunk and I realized he couldn’t walk anymore so was carrying him, but he got too heavy and I put him down. Then he was gone! I don’t know what to do!”
Allison asks him how much they had to drink.
“Alex was really drunk,” George says. “Annika had maybe only a half a drink, but this was her first time out and I don’t think she knows how to get back. I feel responsible, and I’m not sure what to do.”
“Are you drunk?” We ask him. George admits that he has had quite a few drinks. Not really sure of the seriousness of the dilemma, we advice George to go back to the road and look for them, and in a couple minutes, if they don’t show up, wake up Soma and work out a more serious search party.
George rushes off to the street. All the while, I’ve been growing increasingly tired and have to go to sleep. At this point, I’m more tired than worried. So I say goodnight to Allison pick up one of the guitars from the courtyard and tell Jason I’m going to bed.
The next morning in yoga, I ask Allison if Annika and Alex made it home OK, but she hasn’t heard anything either. After the class I find George to make sure everyone made it home all right and he tells me both are back at the center.
Later, in culture and civilization, Jason walks in looking tired and sits next to me. I say good morning and ask him how he’s doing.
“I’m doing all right. I had a pretty crazy night though, searching for Alex.”
He tells details of what happened: The two men on bikes offered them rides when the club closed. They hopped on and nearly immediately split up and took them in separate directions. The one with the men on it dropped them off about a mile from the center, so they started walking the rest of the way. Alex was really, really, drunk. He was going in and out of consciousness and George tried to carry him but couldn’t. Somehow, the pair got split up and Alex got into a rickshaw.
Instead of taking Alex home, the rickshaw driver brought him to the outskirts of town, and stole the money from his wallet, his coin box, his camera and his memory card before dropping him off in the middle of nowhere.
Sometime during George’s walk home, a local asked him for the time. So George took out his cell phone to tell it to him. The local proceeded to grab the phone from him and run away. George ran after him, but the man jumped into a rickshaw and drove off before George could catch up. So George ran home, alone, as fast as possible.
As for Annika, the man on with the motorbike drove her to the woods somewhere, and from what I can understand, tried to have sex with her. I don’t know whether he was forceful or not. Much later, he drove her back to Dhvanyaloka (home).
When George came back after looking for Alex and Annika, he told Jason what happened and they woke up Soma. Soma woke up the guard. Then the man went out in search of Alex. They went up and down the street but weren’t having any luck. They ran into a couple of Iraqis and told them what was going on. The Iraqis immediately joined in the search party.
A little later, one of them said they saw a white man stumbling around on a nearby street. Jason and George knew it must be Alex. They finally found him and brought him back.
“It was so terrifying,” Jason says to me. He’s pretty shaken by the whole event.
Alex is quiet and looking troubled all day, I ask how he’s doing. “Well, I’m here. It was a learning experience, that’s for sure. A hard one, but a needed one,” he replies.
Remember what I wrote about love? This just made me angry. Of course I realize that the group made a lot of stupid choices: getting way too drunk, accepting rides from strangers, etc. etc. And I’m sure they’ll never ever do these things again, but the people here so easily took advantage of them. I knew there were a lot of crooks around – overcharging us here and there - but it just made me feel like everyone in Mysore are corrupt criminals. I got pretty turned off to the people here. It’s just discouraging.
This morning, tow days after the fact, Alex is on his balcony playing him mandolin and I’m here writing with my balcony door open. I ask him if he got angry about how easily people opted to take advantage of him, or if he just felt angry with himself for acting like an idiot.
“It’s a complicated situation,” he tells me. “At first I felt angry at them, and then at myself for getting into the situation. I’ve been in things like this back home – never to this extent – but similar. But then I just felt back that I got George and everyone so worried. I felt really bad that George felt in some ways responsible and people had to run around looking for me.”
I feel this is a very natural response.
I get to thinking about it all. I wonder what makes a criminal. I’m not talking crimes like pot smoking or speeding. Not merely breaking laws, I mean the ones that clearly contradict sound moral judgment, and are harmful to other people. What makes people do these bad things? All too often, I think we think a criminal is a just criminal. We tend to think about it in a vacuum, immediately dismissing the fact that there is a context.
I’m not saying I think people are completely innately good; we possess just as much capacity for evil as we do for good. But I think when our lives are going well and we feel happy, we lean towards doing good, not bad.
I’m under the impression that if we want to solve, or even understand a problem, we need to think about the causes of the problem. I think criminality is a symptom of a problem, not merely a problem in itself.
The first cause that comes to mind to me is “desperation.”
I think, “desperation has to be the cause of all crime.” By desperation, I mean lack of basic human rights – hunger, shelter, lack of dignity. When we reach a place of desperation, things don’t matter the same way. We begin to feel like it doesn’t matter what we do - no one cares about us, we don't care about them. The line between good and bad just vanishes and there is no longer a need to think before we act. The thought process becomes so chaotic, or vanishes altogether that random acts of violence are a reality – it’s a strange mixture of hopelessness and freedom.
This desperation may be the cause of murders, rapes, even terrorism.
But when I think a little further, I realize there’s another cause of violence: boredom.
Boredom, which leads to greed, must the opposite of desperation. It’s when we have everything we need and are so taken care of that things don't matter the same way. We begin to feel like it doesn't matter what we do. Think about when you're bored. it means you don't need to work to get anything. The mind has nothing to focus on, and like the state of desperation, it becomes chaotic and random. I guess this is what's meant be "idle hands are the devils playground."
So boredom leads to greed. What can we have that we don't need? What can we get away with? I think this must be the cause of a lot of middle-class crime, white collar crime, corporate crime, which is equally as harmful.
I bet we all feel both poles at some point or another, but it's sad that we've come to a world where people are in a constant state of one or another, and troubling that there's such a divide, where a person can be so bad off that they are desperate at the same time her neighbor can be so "well off" that she's bored.
Your thoughts?
3 comments:
First of all I can't believe that happened to your friends! Especially that one of the guys tried to rape the girl. Please promise me you'll be careful.
On another note, it's funny you should choose to write about this particular topic. One of the courses I'm taking is a study of genocide and the psychology behind those who instigate mass murder. The textbook is written by a psychologist who essentially makes the exact same points you do.
I agree with you for the most part, however I have to wonder if boredom can really cause people to abandon their morals the way you suggest. I definitely follow your thought process, but I'm not sure I believe that people will kill someone just because they are bored. Maybe this is because that's such a disturbing concept I don't want to believe it. Either way, you definitely got me thinking.
I would say it boils down to greed.
I do think everyone's inatly good. I have to believe people start off good- it's all that gets me through the day sometimes, but I think it's only until you've been in these situations or realy observed them that you think about what makes people do them.
Poverty is one. Oppression from cultural differences is another. Taking advantage of what's there and greed. The one I've never been able to understand is what makes people thin they can rape someone. I still haven't figured that out for our culture let alone this one. Maybe it's greed, maybe it's boredom, maybe it's a combination and something else.
I am less concerned about Alex and George. I feel bad for George, I think Alex is an idiot after your discription of him, but I feel bad for Annika. Because even if "nothing happened" something happened in the fact that she went through that situation that night. The attempt of rape will affect her just as much.
Stay well dear.
P.S. Do you really need to change your blog name? I understand this is for professional reasons, but I think it depends what you're going into.
My blog is for me and I think it compliments that one day I will want to go into an alternative media industry. But obviously I'll be searching for jobs elsewhere. Anyway-- I hope you can still find a spunky name. Your blog has a bite to it- I would hate that not to be shown in the title.
Post a Comment